Skip to main content

Can't touch that

One might not have heard of a temple called Shani Shingnapur before a group of women activist decided they wanted to enter the temple. There isn't really a ban on the entry of women in the temple (unlike Sabrimala), the ban/prohibition is for touching or offering oil to the deity. This hardly should be news. There might be 100s of temples where women are prohibited to enter where the idol is or to touch it. So my very first reaction to this was, a big SO WHAT? This is what years and years of conditioning does to you. As a woman/girl, you so often hear these words:"You can't do this", that I have probably become immune to the ones that seem frivolous to me. Yes I'm not a big worshipper.

So what is the big deal here?
Hinduism is really big on idol worship, if you hadn't noticed. An idol to us is a form of God, and hence the need to keep it "pure". Temple which have these bans, cite menstruation as the cause. Women are considered impure during their monthly cycles.

I like to think our ancestors (the ones who were capable of writing Vedas) were super rational and intelligent humans. They probably lived very practical lives for their times and then passed on their learnings to their offsprings and so on. Somewhere in the middle of this chain, the offsprings became too comfortable and stopped wondering & questioning. Customs were to be followed, rituals were to be performed as is. This is what I call as the dumbing down of the generations. ( I am definitely much much dumber than my father, with practically no life skills).
So the smart women of that time paused for a minute and thought, how do we get out of these house chores for a few days. Menstrual bleeding was the perfect break : me time. Not having sanitary pads/tampons also might have helped their cause. Periods were the headache of our modern world. I guess it might have been quite messy to have bleeding women around anywhere. Quite naturally these women would have avoided public places and specially temples which are supposed to be pristine clean. It is possible it became like an unwritten rule: Women don't enter temples during their periods. (I might be wrong there may be a written rule somehwere) The point is, this was a very practical solution for then.
Now, when there is absolutely no way of knowing whether the woman is menstruating, unless you overhear me constantly complaining of cramps, what does the poor priest do? He can't ask every woman in the temple. He has stopped asking questions several generations ago. He can recite shlokas from memory though. The natural thing for this priest is to prohibit women near the idol.
The sad part is, women still believe they are "impure".

The women who are fighting their right to offer oil to Shani Dev, I am quite confident none of them will enter the temple during their periods. You have my support & blessings when you want to fight that fight.

PS: I initially thought maybe temples had the right to entry, but since they aren't private properties they don't. I might be simplifying here, but weren't backward classes refused (are still refused) entry to worship houses because of "impurity".

Few more links, if you're interested in facts.
http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/do-you-have-a-constitutional-right-to-prevent-women-entryat-sabarimala-sc-to-devaswom/article8092924.ece

http://www.legalblog.in/2011/10/distinction-between-math-temple-law.html

http://zeenews.india.com/news/india/maharashtras-shani-shingnapur-why-this-temple-is-so-famous-5-things-you-may-not-know_1849331.html

http://indiafacts.org/casteism-misogyny-and-rights-of-hindu-religious-institutions-iv/

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

An Uneven Playground

Bordering our community wall is a public ground. Although it is neighbours with an active cemetery, the ground is usually teaming with life. Looking at it from our bedroom window is a regular feature in our daily lives. Even on the days we don’t explicitly gaze down, the constant humming arising from part human, part animal & bird’s activity, gently reminds us of its presence.  It’s been 2 years or less since the panchayat/ municipality has cleared off bushes & debris, planted trees at the perimeter, made a pitch and cut access for four wheelers much to the dismay of nouveau drivers. Ever since, the ground has been a hotspot for gully cricketers. Even in the hottest of the summer days, the ground hosts several cricket matches and a couple running in parallel on holidays. It is a no brainer, the ground is a boon for the neighbourhood, but every time I look down, I wonder : Where are the girls? Right across the ground within the walls of our gated community, you can easily sp...

The friendly FOE - Freedom of Expression

Like clockwork, FOE comes back in news every 2-3 months. It's not surprising it comes up this often in this age, where every second person is a blogger (ahem) expressing their views freely to be intercepted by hopefully one or 2 people if he/she is lucky or has any friends. Jokes apart, with millions of people active on social networks it is hard to say something stupid and get away with it. Internet always remembers, but tends to have a short attention span also. A few days back, Tanmay Bhat from AIB made a snapchat video swapping Lata Mangeshkar and Sachin's face. The kind of thing 2 year olds find funny. But then apparently he said some uncool stuff. I haven't watched the video, neither do I intend to. Don't enjoy his kind of humour. Coming back to the video, people were obviously offended about the mockery of their idols. I hate Twitter on such days, everyone is outraging over the same thing (for or against). Just no escaping it. I understand FOE comes bundled w...

When a stranger comes knocking!

Humans are social animals; at the very same time move around in close-knit circles. As we grow older, these circles get tighter and probably smaller. Our chances of meeting and connecting with strangers get slimmer and slimmer.  At a time when conversations between co-passengers during travels are bare minimal, where we shy away even from making an eye contact with a passerby on a street, what happens when a complete stranger comes knocking on your door. Welcome to CouchSurfing . CouchSurfing offers travellers the ability to crash with a local and possibly a guided tour with the host. It is a cheap (maybe not always a safe ) alternative while travelling. In addition to the favorable economics for the traveller and a possibility for the host to travel to the guest’s hometown, the host gets to be part of a memory (hopefully a good one) and who knows a friend for life. As nerve wrecking as it may seem, it is highly recommended!